On Thursday (May 10), during an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, Carrie Underwood debuted a spoof of her hit video for "Before He Cheats," featuring a fanny pack-wearing Jimmy. In "Before You Freak," Jimmy portrays an innocent guy caught up in the wave of destruction caused by Carrie's Louisville Slugger-toting character, as she takes revenge on her cheating boyfriend by totaling his vehicle.

Only problem? She's got the wrong truck.

"It's like 'Before He Cheats' the sequel—what happens next," said Carrie.

As Carrie and Jimmy trade verses during the parody, Carrie takes her aggression out on his 4x4 with a bat, rips up his poster of James Van Der Beek, throws away his Hello Kitty merchandise and tears the head off his Al Gore bobblehead, before realizing the vehicle doesn't belong to her "schmuck" of a boyfriend.

Then Carrie's boyfriend pulls up in an identical truck, and Carrie climbs in, leaving Jimmy behind to mourn the destruction. Watch the hilarious spoof below.